Hmmm... fascinating idea.

Given that I'm gearing up to switching what I vid from BSG to SV, I'm tempted to sign my name up... but given that I've only seen two names on that list of subscribers I recognise, it seems egotistical for me to join in :P

Aww, well you never know... I think I signed up last year but didn't get any concrit. People are so shy!

I only get 6 people watching my vids at the best of times, so my concrit comes from you and m_a_r_i_k_s... and I think I've had more good concrit in one set of draft comments from you than I'll get from most other people in a lifetime ;)

I take it I'm not allowed to say "you're an intimidating person to know as a vidder because your vids are so damn good even with songs I'm not keen on" would count as valid concrit if I went and left it anonymously...

Aww, I'd hope you know me well enough that you can say anything you like to me anyway, including 'dude, that vid? not so much'. And you're totally capable of converting me to music I'm not so there for, as you know!

One of the things I like about having a handful of vidders on my flist is that there are things I admire about all of them, but I don't envy any, if that makes sense?

I love DB's enthusiasm and passion. Vidding may involve angst, but she somehow turns it into one big, bouncing, inspiring squeeful hobby for everyone around her.

Mariks makes the most wonderfully complex vids, in every way possible - she bends and folds and likes and binds and breaks video clips and effects, producing vids I doubt anyone else could produce anything similar too; she's possibly the only person where the first couple of times I watch a vid, I realise afterwards I'm sitting there with my mouth open and can't remember anything other than "that was awesome."

Pi somehow manages to make vids that feel slow and langourous compared to anything I've ever made, and yet they don't feel as if they're lagging, like a lot of vids do; it's more like watching considered, detailed thoughts spreading out.

And there's you, of course - the multi-talented multi-fandom vidder, who can vid half a dozen fandoms with consumate ease, who has the narrative so firmlly in mind that when you vid there's never a wasted clip, not even a half second in a six minute song. Each vid you make is better than the last, and yet there's never a sense of you having hit any sort of ceiling because each is usually more complex than the last, too.

I have the best flist for vidding inspiration :)

Vidding may involve angst, but she somehow turns it into one big, bouncing, inspiring squeeful hobby for everyone around her.
What a sweet sentiment! I'd reply about you in kind, but you know I love your vids and I have squeed about them in the various threads. :-)

These sentiments come at a good time. I am full of vidding angst at the moment and not feeling that bouncy at all. But I will once I get past the latest challenge. And I will get past it. We have to be so . . . stubborn about learning. It's the only way.

Thanks again!

I have the best list for vidding help and inspiration too. :-)

This is the most awesomely warm fuzzy comment of loveliness. \o/ Thank you! you are way TOO kind about my vidding, but I do appreciate it, and even more I appreciate the talks we have about vidding--learning together is so much better than learning alone! And I love your comments about the others too. You should link to it or something to make sure the others see it. ;)